When it comes to putting some decent off road maps on your iPhone or Tablet, these days you really have two choices. Long time printed now digital map producing company Hema Maps and a newish competitor Mud Maps. Before we get too much in the trenches with these two, one thing you should know is that in the most important area (telling you what track are you on) both products do a great job. It’s only the little things that set these two apart.
Hema or Mud Maps V’s nothing? Nothing loses hands down.
Now’s the time to complete completely overthink how to choose one over the other in the rest of this post 😃
The companies
Hema:
Hema is a Queensland company that’s been around since the 80s. It was through stealing my fathers printed maps that I first discovered them. Whilst they could have become irrelevant with the digital revolution they were smart enough and wealthy enough to evolve. Firstly (and still) with their own built for purpose digital devices, and today into the multi talented phones and tablets we all carry around with us.
My relationship with Hema has always been a bit of a torn one. They always seemed to be out-of-reach expensive as I was growing up and getting into off roading. I remember a mates father showing me his Hema GPS and whilst it was stupidly hard to use, was 2 times more expensive than a normal car GPS I thought to myself wow… off road maps will never be the same. And then… Greedy F##krs.
But really I had no idea of the economics of it all, and my comparison was not based on the ‘more you make the cheaper it is’ principle, and whilst everyone wanted a car GPS only a fraction want an offload version, so of course it would be expensive.
I also didn’t pay them with the dues that this additional price gave them the capability to invest and evolve with technology. Bringing us the best solutions that the current technology allowed.
So now I’m now coming around
Mud Maps:
This crew couldn’t be any more of a contradiction to Hema Maps. They’re new, and there’s not a lot of information about them — based in Victoria, owned by some company called equips solutions. The company itself has been around since 2003, but the business name it trades under has only been around since 2010. You’ll struggle to find an address or a phone number.
There’s for sure some weirdness and a specific effort to hide a bunch of information on who they are, and where you find them. Makes me wonder.
The other main difference is they that they are a technology first company they’re not map makers turned technologists. I see both as a good thing and a bad thing. It could mean there app has more features, might be easier to use, but without the history in mapping they might not understand what’s important to us navigators. Hard to tell on that one as a the worlds most comprehensive app is pointless if people can’t figure out how to use it.
The cost
For the purposes of this comparison I purchased both these apps from the App store. This is really the only moment of any real rage in the process.
- First Mud Maps. $125 in the App Store. WTF! That is crazy town
- Second HEMA. $99.95 in the App Store WTF but a little less.
Both these maps are excessive, and whilst I don’t mind paying for digital things, I feel they’ve gone a little to far against the grain.
To further add to the rage…. you still have in app purchases to buy even more maps… your $100 bickies doesn’t even get you all the maps.
The Support
You only really care about how good a companies support is when you need it. So the company with the ultimate in support has processes and a project so good, no one ever needs help. Sadly the I’ve never found one yet.
Both Hema and Mud Maps do pretty good here. They have lots of help articles, active on social media and have direct feedback channels (forums/forms online). Hema probably do edge out Mud Maps as they actually have an address and a phone number.
The Alternatives
There isn’t actually a heap of choice here. You can read about my old OziExplorer setup. There’s a cheaper version of Hema maps for $29.99 and you could but the independent Hema GPS for a small fortune. But really, right now if you want good off-road navigation these are your two choices.
The Apps themselves
I’m a bit of a nerd, so I find it pretty easy to pick up apps. For a fairer test I sat down the old man who’s much less technology inclined and asked him to use the apps. Surprisingly, whilst the Mud Maps App looked better, the old boy figured out the Hema maps more quickly.
It was pretty close though — he was able to wrap his head around both pretty quickly.
Feature sets are pretty similar, and whilst both apps exist I’m sure they’ll add and copy each others functionality so will never be that far apart.
From a ‘will they do what they say they will perspective’ I think they are pretty evenly match as well. Reading of the reviews on Mud Maps latest version MM3, there’s a few people that might disagree with me.
Which would I buy?
Right now I would probably lean towards the Hema maps, really due to seemingly being more ‘legit’ as a company and also with their long history of maps for the 4×4 community. They also have the cheaper Hema explorer for those that have a little less coin.
It still doesn’t curb the rage at a $100 app with additional in app purchases though.
If you do decide to go the Mud Maps option though, I’m pretty sure you’ll be okay.
We do need a really someone with the community in mind.
I’d love to buddy up with a site like 4x4earth and build a true community mapping and camping app that we can share with the off-road community for a lot lot less. But that a dream (or maybe a kickstarter) for another time.
Be sure to let us know if you went Hema or Mud Maps in the comments.
Had a look and Mud Maps V3 is now down to 99.99 – but the Hema at the same price has lots of addon maps to purchase – are these needed ?
I’ve never had to buy any additional maps with HEMA. The standard set have always worked perfectly for me.
My old man and I recently finished a 3500km road trip from Kununarra WA to the south west via the Gibb using first edition Mud Maps on an Ipad mini mounted on the dash. Found it very good and easy to use, the detail in maps was great and most important accurate.
I think people who are in the market for these type of apps need to be prepared to use bulk data downloading maps they will need for the areas they intend to visit, as there are several style of maps for each. Assuming they are out of mobile signal.
Hope that makes sense…..
Mud maps – worst support i have ever seen. These guys do not stand by their product at all. I have issues with their M7, and truthfully cant comment on the app, however these guys lie, cheat and do anything to get out of their obligations under the law. I had to take my warranty issues up with the department of commerce in VIC to get an outcome. If their attitude is anything to say about how they do business, i suggest stay away. This is my experience – hate to be this negative but these guys just pushed me way too far.
Ive been comparing MM3 and Hema apps. I get the impression MM has detailed maps only for the east coast. For example, they don’t have maps for SA. Am I correct?
pretty sure they have full AU coverage, but I’ll ask for you gks
I have mud maps 2 which is now obsolete. This app was purchased 3 years ago about 6 month prior to mud maps 3 being released.
I will not recommend mud maps as they can change their app and charge for the new app.
Not sure about Hema but don’t get caught with product the is only supported for a couple years and then they recharge you.
Mud maps response to the upgrade is to keep your iPad on the earlier OS!
Really!!!
Also unhappy with Mud Maps upgrade path!
When the new IOS11 upgrade came in I was aware that my 3 year old version of MM2 would no longer work if I upgraded my iPad Air2.
The iPad forced an upgrade, waking up one day and finding it had updated itself overnight without any input from me.
I now have a useless version of a $100 piece of software that I WAS extremely happy with and had used quite a bit.
Mud Map support was responsive but not particularly sympathetic, basically offering a $25 rebate if I mail in my invoice on purchase of MM3.
They have done this before on the MM1 to MM3 upgrade.
I wouldn’t mind paying a bit to continue using MM2, which I am very happy with, or pay for MM3 upgrade with a DECENT discount.
Seriously looking at my options now as I am seriously P****d off!
I think that around $100 for any of these mapping softwares is seriously good value, and I would be more than prepared to fork up an extra $25-$50 to get an upgrade to a newer version of a software I am satisfied with and familiar with using.
This is the reason I will probably go for Hema this time rather than continue supporting Mud Maps whose business model is one I dislike.
HEMA Maps recently released a iOS 11 sending out emails saying look what were done. The app loaded on two different iOS devices crashes after opening and many others are reporting the same. Not good enough HEMA and I pay for an annual pro subscription.
Be prepared to re-purchase mud map every 2 years as they release a new version and refuse to update the old version which then becomes incompatible with phone updates!
hm, MudMap have 25k topo nationwide included and you can purchase the excellent SV 4wd maps for victoria (12$ per map) for Hema 4wd app you need to purchase topo 25k for $100 per state. Hema Explore seems to have topo maps but has a horrible contrast in it’s maps you need to have very good eyes to distiguish between tracks and features. I should mention I have all 3 apps
Great write up Shayne. After reading comparisons and the comments from the guys that have MM’s I’m going with Hema. Thanks to all for making the choice easier.
That’s what we try to do here! Which we could do more.
Great review but one area that I would like supports the Hema app over of Mad Maps app is that you don’t have to purchase a newer version of the app after you do a major upgrade of your ISO. Initially I had been a big user and supporter of Mud Maps in 2012 when it was previously called VMS then the name changed to Mud Map at $150 plus over $100 optional maps. This love affair started to fade only after approximately 2 and bits years as I was asked to fork out another $150 for Mad Map 2 or lose all my saved maps and trip data. In 2017 Mud Map put a gun to my head again for another $150 for Mud Maps 3! I might add that I also run Hema in parallel since 2014 and have never had to pay for upgrade. I complained to Mud maps but thay said that it was not their fault as they have no control over the ISO developers and needed to develop a new app. What an insult if Hema running parallel over the same time why can’t Mad Maps? Like you commented now way of calling them somewhere in Vic you would do to STAY WELL AWAY FROM MUD MAPS. Needless to say after spending over $400 on a app that doesn’t work and lost all my trip data over the years should have just stuck to Hema and save the money for paper maps.
Mudmap was always mudmap, I have the original still (and it still works on latest iOS but is laggy as hell and almost not useable.
I paid for $60 worth of extra maps on mudmap1, then I purchased mudmap 2 as 1 doesn’t work properly on iPad (screen was too small in app)
In between 1 and 2 they released HD which was when the company changed hands, they adopted the HD model for 2, it was pretty buggy but it worked….ios11 update made mudmap 2 and HD stopped working, I missed out on the discount by just under 2 months.
I was told that they are using their all new mudmap 3 model, and will continue to update it with new iOS versions, I believe it is still better value than Hema
Just be careful purchasing MudMaps. You will get to a point there they no longer update the app and make a new version which will force you into buying it or keeping old software on your device with very little compensation